Pizza in Gahanna, OH (That Actually Lives Up to the Hype)
If you searched “pizza in Gahanna” and ended up here, congrats — you’re one decision away from a dangerously good night.
We make 90s-kid dream pizza: crispy edges, soft middle, bold toppings, and a menu that refuses to be boring.
Start with the legends
– Order The Mario
– Order The Eugene (Monthly Special when active)
– Order Garlic Knots
Why locals pick Pizza Nerds
– A vibe straight out of the 90s (arcade energy, no-tryhard fun)
– Hand-made, locally sourced ingredients (we don’t do shortcuts)
– Specialty pizzas with actual personality (Mario, Doug, Donkey Kong…)
– Epic house-baked cookies for the “one more thing” moment
Menu highlights (order the greatest hits)
Suggested lineup:
– The Mario
– Captain Planet
– The Doug
– The Donkey Kong
– Garlic Knots
– Cookies 2 for $6
Detroit-style pizza vibes (without the boring lecture)
Our specialty pizzas are pan-baked with crispy edges and a soft, squishy center — the kind of slice that hits like your favorite throwback show.
Want the full breakdown? Hit our Detroit-style pizza page.
Visit our Gahanna location
We’re based at our Gahanna location — check hours, directions, and pickup details.
FAQs
What style of pizza do you serve?
Specialty pizzas with pan-baked, crispy-edge energy — plus thin options. Start with The Mario if you want a safe “wow.”
Can I order online?
Yes — hit order online and you’ll jump right into the item you want.
Do you sell cookies too?
Yep. 1/4lb cookies, rotating flavors, and dangerously easy to add to your cart.